DreamTheaterForums.org Dream Theater Fan Site
Dream Theater => Dream Theater => Topic started by: Ħ on January 27, 2012, 06:18:59 PM
-
I think it is. I really think it is. It's so energetic, so lively, yet not in a corny metal way. The two solos are very tasteful, there's no fluff, LaBrie nails the delivery...if there's anything to complain about, it's that it's very cookie-cutter DT, but really that's nothing to complain about...I am really very impressed with OTBOA, even to the point where I'd say it's better than TCOT or anything else since 8VM. It's that good.
-
I think it is. I really think it is. It's so energetic, so lively, yet not in a corny metal way. The two solos are very tasteful, there's no fluff, LaBrie nails the delivery...if there's anything to complain about, it's that it's very cookie-cutter DT, but really that's nothing to complain about...I am really very impressed with OTBOA, even to the point where I'd say it's better than TCOT or anything else since 8VM. It's that good.
It's hard being wrong, but at least you're graceful about it.
-
Thank you. :)
-
It's hard being wrong, but at least you're graceful about it.
-
It's hard being wrong, but at least you're graceful about it.
-
It's hard being wrong, but at least you're graceful about it.
This. But honorable mention for JP's solo and the following LTE-esque section. :metal
-
It's hard being wrong, but at least you're graceful about it.
-
It's a great song, but Lost Not Forgotten, Bridges in the Sky, and Breaking All Illusions are on ADTOE as well.
-
No.
Great song, but, no.
-
Top 3 from that album. Very great song.
-
Nah, it's easily the worst song on the album.
-
You people are weird.
-
-
-
Nah, it's easily the worst song on the album.
:tup
-
Top 3 from that album. Very great song.
:tup
Only bettered by BAI and BITS for me
-
It's a great song, but Lost Not Forgotten, Bridges in the Sky, and Breaking All Illusions are on ADTOE as well.
This - but, really, nothing could be worse than everything after 6DOIT. This album renewed my faith in their ability to actually write good songs!
-
That's understandable. They did rewrite Images And Words afterall. :neverusethis:
-
If "Constant Motion" was the oldest son - good, but a bit reckless and wild - and "A Rite Of Passage" was the awkward middle-child that never got enough attention - then "On The Backs Of Angels" is the smart, interesting kid with great ideas.
I do rank OTBOA pretty high on the album, and even among other DT songs, especially the latter-era "singles".
-Marc.
-
It's a great song, but Lost Not Forgotten, Bridges in the Sky, and Breaking All Illusions are on ADTOE as well.
This - but, really, nothing could be worse than everything after 6DOIT. This album renewed my faith in their ability to actually write good songs!
Everything? Surely some of the songs on TOT and 8VM aren't that bad.
-
I like it, but it's not the best from ADTOE. Top 5 for sure, but not the best. And for a lead-off single, it's surprisingly complex compared to AROP or CM
-
It's a great song, but it's on the same album as Breaking All Illusions and Bridges in the Sky, so sorry, no, it isn't.
-
Good song.
-
I like the song a lot, but it's not the best on the album. LNF, BITS, TITL, BAI are better imo. I actually find OTBOA to be a bit sterile for DT, although well written enough.
-
I love OTBoA but it comes second to last on my favorites of the nine tracks on ADToE. What an album.
-
It's indeed a great song, but the best? Personally I'd rank it somewhere in the middle, with BAI right smack on top.
-
Right behind Bridges in the sky, Breaking all illusions and Beneath the surface. Brilliant song.
-
Nah, it's easily the worst song on the album.
¿Seriously? ¿Worse than BMUBMD? :huh:
IMO, OTBOA is a great song, but TITL, BAI, BITS and maybe Outcry are better.
-
It's good, but not even Top 3 on the album.
-
It's the best for me. It's because when I listen to the guitar intro and then the song building up, I remember that day when I was constantly hitting refresh waiting for it on Roadrunner's channel and waiting to listen to the new DT. It has been connected with a memory so it has become kind of special compared to the other songs.
-
Not the best on the album, but it is a very good song. ADTOE is a very strong album
-
God knows for how long this song blew my mind.... spent days and days giving it listens and I was about to lose it.. it made me love my all-time-fave band even more.... that effect decreased once the album came out... mostly because of overhearing it... I'm bloody sure that its ranking would be higher (for me) if it came out along with the rest of the songs.....
It is fantastic!
-
Not the best, but it's a fantastic song.
-
No, but you are entitled to your own opinion... even if it's wrong :P
-
Breaking All Illusions and Outcry are easily better than it. Bridges In The Sky and possibly Lost Not Forgotten too. So not the best on ADTOE, it is good though. Oh, and several from Black Clouds and Systematic Chaos are better.
-
My least favourite on the album but that still leaves it being a really good song. I don't usually waste my time ranking songs on an album, even though I'm a DT fan ;D. Do I skip it? Occasionally, but not often. Do I skip any of the others? No. Do I sometimes skip straight to BAI before going back to the start of the album? Guilty as charged.
-
Well i kinda agree with the OP, although there are great epic songs in this album, i keep finding myself wanting to listen to OTBOA more and more. Its an amazing song.
-
Great song. I loved it at first listen, but it's not the best on ADToE. I rank LNF and BitS higher and maybe BAI too.
It IS better than everything on BC&SL and a lot of SC though, but that's not saying much.
-
Rock solid song, and a fine opener, but the best song on ADTOE? No way. To me, it is only better than Lost Not Forgotten, and even that is pretty close. But it speaks volumes as to how strong the album is as a whole when the least best songs are that good. :tup :tup
-
Real hard for me to put another song before Breaking All Illusions. And not just from this album. This song is easily one of my most favorite songs ever! Still listen to it a lot and it is impressive every time!
I love On The Backs Of Angels a lot though. A very classic one.
-
OTBOA is near the top at this point and was the best choice for first single and album opener. Love it and never skip it. BITS and BAI are the best for me on ADTOE. Can't choose between the two.