My issue is with copying and pasting performances from other shows into the same song. So, yes, the parts are live, but if they're all cobbled together from different shows, it's not really live. Again, pseudo-live, and again, a personal peeve of mine (it annoys me to no end that Live At The Marquee was ruined for me when I found out James's voice was overdubbed big time in the studio). Plenty of bands released live shows without having to resort to such exhaustive means; curating the performances in such a way removes all the magic of live because you know it's not even a real show you're listening to, just someone cobbling parts together. That's just how I feel about it. It doesn't tell me the band is confident in their live shows when they resort to something like that. Again... just me. I don't care if there are flubs or it's not the 100% greatest live performance ever, but don't release something with live tracks that aren't actually the real thing and contain tracks from other shows.... if a concert is from September 12th in Poland, I want to hear what was played that night, damn it, not 80% of the song and 20% of it from a show the week before, that's stupid.