I'm not a White Stripes fan, so media play is my only real impression of them. I'm just saying the song I linked was the first impression of White Stripes for many people and it created a "this band isn't the greatest guitarist/drummer" feel that will be hard to break, first impressions and all. He's obviously become much better.
And yes, the drums were the worst part. And as anybody that has played in a band will tell you, a sucky drummer makes the entire band sound bad.
Never made a comment on whether or not the White Stripes songs were "worthy". That's an entirely different subject. There are very few songs that I would ever feel are universally bad (can't even name one in my head right now). Otherwise, they just simply *aren't my cup of tea*. I got over the "but I hone my craft, so this isn't fair" stigma decades ago.