After a dozen listens or so, with only one in head phones (and a couple in the car), I'd have to say...this is better than I expected it to be, and I was expecting it to be AMAZING, so it's beyond that.
They weren't kidding when they said this album had a good mix of their styles, sounds, and respective genres thrown in. I don't know TOO much about Steve Morse or Dave LaRue, in terms of their playing styles, but what they've provided on this album is just STUNNING, especially LaRue's bass mix. It seems like whenever Neal records an album, his bass mixes just get better and better. He is 3 for 3 (Trewavas on The Whirlwind, George on Testimony 2, and now LaRue on Flying Colors).
There's a LOT of tasty guitar riffs on here from Steve, some great key work from Neal, and above-par drumming from Mike. He knows exactly when to show off and when to hold back on here, and he doesn't over play (well, maybe a LITTLE, but he IS Mike). Casey's voice is just amazing. I keep imagining I'm hearing the song on the radio because of his pop-sounding voice, but then I realize I'm listening to rock legends behind him and go "Whoa, wait...is this really happening?" and as the songs and album progress, it becomes a magical melding of their talents. I'd have to say, the sum is greater than it's parts on here, and each song is great in it's own way. I've grown to love the first four tracks in order, and the last few.
I think this album has the potential to be a Top 5 album of 2012 for me. It's going to grow and grow and age from a great album to an even greater one. Even my girlfriend, who isn't into prog (or any music I listen to) TOO much liked this album. Not sure if it was Casey's voice, or the song writing, but this album has wide-spread appeal, so I hope this album really takes off.
On a side-note, IF they plan to tour, I've wonder what they'd play to fill out half their set? I'd *love* to see them play "Mystery Train" by Transatlantic (well, HALF of TA is Flying Colors, so why not??)...also, any songs from Neal's first two solo albums would be awesome, especially the 20 minute epic "A Whole Nother Trip".
-Marc.