Porcupine Tree Survivor - Lightbulb Sun - Round 5

[RoeDent]

ROUND 4 RESULTS

Shesmovedon - 1
Where We Would Be - 9
Russia On Ice - 2
Feel So Low - 5

No worries about ties this time round. Where We Would Be is eliminated by a clear margin. First song from the second half of the album to go.

Ranking

1.
2.
----------
3.
----------
4.
5.
6. Where We Would Be
7= Last Chance to Evacuate Planet Earth Before It Is Recycled
  = The Rest Will Flow
9. How Is Your Life Today
10. Four Chords That Made A Million

---------------------------

Into the top 5 then. 24 hours to vote.

[Mladen]

Russia On Ice

It's really good, just not THAT good.

[Evermind]

Feel So Low

Thanks.

[hefdaddy42]

Feel So Low

[Crow]

this won't get votes, but Hatesong

[Evermind]

this won't get votes, but Hatesong

This is my next vote.

[bout to crash]

Feel So Low

Thanks.

 

Yeah, this should not be in the top five...

[7deg_inner_happiness]

Feel So Low

Thanks.

 

Yeah, this should not be in the top five...

Agreed.

[Crow]

this won't get votes, but Hatesong

This is my next vote.

yeah but people don't like Feel So Low which is actually superior to most of the songs on the album so nobody is voting it this round

[Lolzeez]

WOW SERIOUSLY GUYS VOTING OFF A TOP 10 PT SONG... 

Hatesong

[Buddyhunter1]

WOW SERIOUSLY GUYS VOTING OFF A TOP 10 PT SONG... 

Hatesong

Oh the irony.

Anyways, I voted for Shesmovedon. Hopefully it's the next one to go after Feel So Low, because the title track, Hatesong, and Russia On Ice are all top-tier Porcupine Tree.

[Lolzeez]

WOW SERIOUSLY GUYS VOTING OFF A TOP 10 PT SONG... 

Hatesong

Oh the irony.

Anyways, I voted for Shesmovedon. Hopefully it's the next one to go after Feel So Low, because the title track, Hatesong, and Russia On Ice are all top-tier Porcupine Tree.

Dude stop voting for my fav tracks 

[Elite]

The only song that's top-tier PT material here is Shesmovedon, and even the Deadwing version is much, much better than it. Honestly, Lightbulb Sun is for me one of their worst albums.

[Evermind]

The only song that's top-tier PT material here is Shesmovedon, and even the Deadwing version is much, much better than it. Honestly, Lightbulb Sun is for me one of their worst albums.

Wow. I'm totally on the opposite side here.

[Zantera]

LBS is a mixed bag for me. Hatesong, Russia on Ice, Lightbulb Sun and Last Chance would all be in my top15 PT songs, but literally half of the album is throwaway tracks. It has nothing on Stupid Dream.

I went with Feel So Low, because it has some of the worst PT lyrics and some really cringeworthy delivery IMO. I would be fine with Shesmovedon going as well, that song ain't special.

[RoeDent]

 

[Crow]

I think Last Chance would be the only song here to crack my top 10 or 15.
On the other hand I still haven't listened to half their albums, so

[Lolzeez]

The only song that's top-tier PT material here is Shesmovedon, and even the Deadwing version is much, much better than it. Honestly, Lightbulb Sun is for me one of their worst albums.

Wow. I'm totally on the opposite side here.

Me too,in fact this is probably my second favorite PT album following Deadwing.

[Buddyhunter1]

LBS is a mixed bag for me. Hatesong, Russia on Ice, Lightbulb Sun and Last Chance would all be in my top15 PT songs, but literally half of the album is throwaway tracks.

Same. It's very split, with some of the band's best songs and a bunch of ones I don't care for. It's not one of their most cohesive-sounding albums, either. That said, due to the sheer quality of some of the songs, it would probably be in my top five PT albums.

[?]

LBS is one of my least favorite albums as well. Half the album is filler, and even the good songs aren't amazing.