Finished Andromeda, with about 75 hours play time. Really, really liked it. I didn't start playing until a number of patches had been released, plus another one was issued when I was around halfway through, so animation was tidied up and glitches were clearly heavily reduced. But other than that, I don't know what all the fuss was about or why people have disliked it. It takes a while to get into, both gameplay- and story-wise, but once it gets going it's great fun to play and the story and characters are solid.
Overall I'd say it's definitely not as good as ME 2 and 3, but I'd put it on a par with their other games. In comparison to ME1, the narrative isn't as tight, but it's a lot more fun to play, so on balance I rate it around the same level.
It also opens up lots of intriguing narrative arcs that I hope they explore either in DLC or sequels. I know EA said it's on hold for the time being, though that seemed to imply that they're simply not working on a follow up right now, but hopefully there'll at least be some DLC and they'll come back to it later on.