That scoring system is silly.
As far as picking a lineup, it depends. I mean, are we talking about in terms of our favorite musical output during their prime? I'd go with the classic lineup in a heartbeat. Are we talking about current abilities? If so, I'd probably go with the current lineup. I mean, it's tempting to want Scott back in at drums and Chris back in on guitar. But Scott seems to have gone off the deep end, and I'm not even sure has the desire and motivation do justice to the music, new or old. And I think we all know that, although Chris's head seems screwed on right, wherever his head is, it isn't in making music with QR. And Parker is really great at fitting both their classic sound and their modern sound. So honestly, while the current lineup may not feel "ideal," it is probably the best version of Queensryche possible at the present time.