You can't really judge consistency with those two eras though. You have four albums from Fish (2 of which are amazing, 2 of which are average, IMO) and what, 11 from Hogarth? Yeah there are going to be a few duds. h gave us Season's End, Marbles, Happiness is the Road, Marillion.com, Anoraknophobia, Brave, and Afraid of Sunlight. I'd say that puts h above Fish easily.