Yeah, that was exactly it. Suburby. I really liked it there. When we took the ferry to Manhattan, I couldn't, in good consience, leave Mahattan without having had a slice of pizza, so we went to Georgio's on Beaver Street, not far from the terminal. WOW was that good shit.
We stayed at the Comfort Inn down by Fresh Kills. Joe and Pat's did have very good pizza. One of the beat cops at the St. George terminal recommended J&P's. Nunzio's I'd seen recommended online. It was very good as well, but the waitress was a little bitchy. So we were there the afternoon and evening Saturday and Sunday morning, and we didn't get to do a whole lot. But definitely next time we're out that way, I'll give a shout.