This is Losing Time from San Jose: https://youtu.be/APgguUhugfA?t=2656
Best one from this tour, i think.
I said "eff it" and decided to listen to this show.
Rather than just relying on people to highlight the "bad" parts. How "bad" is James, really?
Here's my full analysis.
1. The Alien - Overall, Good
I divided James' performance into a few parts.
"First Verse", "Prechorus", "Chorus", "Bridge/Post-Chorus".
He sounded "Good" on the first and second verses, prechoruses, and post-choruses.
He sounded a wee bit pitchy on the first two choruses.
He sounded fine on the final chorus, maybe slightly pitchy on the outro part "I'm the Alien".
On the whole, I think his performance was Good, and within what I'd consider a reasonable and professional expectation for the singer. Lots of applause too.
2. Sleeping Giant - Fair
"First verse" - Good, including a good high note in there at the end of the first verse.
"Chorus" - Starts off a bit pitchy, and misses a few notes. Never really regains footing, and just seems off for most of the chorus.
"2nd verse" - Very good, seems to have recovered. Good job on the more anthemic "Wooooah".
"2nd Chorus" - A bit better than the first, but still sounds a little off where he is waving in and out of key.
"Final Chorus" - Same as the first two. Maybe the strongest of the lot, but just passable.
"Outro" - This is fine.
Overall, not a great performance. He seems to struggle with the chorus of this song in particular.
Given that it's brand new material, I find it hard to understand.
3. Caught in a Web - Poor
First Verse - A bit pitchy, but settles in alright.
Prechorus - Same, but the opposite. It starts poorly and kinda improves toward the end.
Chorus - Surprisingly good, until "Spinning the Lies". He just can't hit that note. It's not distractingly bad or anything.
2nd Verse - Starts fine, but gets progressively worse. He just can't hit those notes and the replacement melody isn't great.
3rd verse - Nice improv on a note he can't hit anymore, in fact this part sounds a lot better overall than the 2nd verse.
Final chorus - Same as above.
Overall, a relatively poor performance of a song that he just doesn't have in the tank anymore. I'm not sure anyone expects him to nail this, and here he clearly does not.
4. Answering the Call - Poor
First verse - Good. Somewhat pitchy toward the end.
Chorus - Pitchy, pitchy, pitchy.
2nd Verse - He just sounds off on a lot this. Misses the high note before the "prechorus" sounding part.
2nd Chorus - Same, tbh.
Bridge - Sounds a bit better.
Final Chorus - Seems a little bit better this time around. Overall, though, a rough performance.
5. Solitary Shell - Good
First verse - Sounds more or less. Some kinda weird JLBistic ad-libs, but decent.
Prechorus - A little pitchy, but not that bad. I'd say it was fine.
Chorus - Pretty good! Even the higher stuff sounds pretty good, and I was bracing myself. I don't get all the adlibbed "hyea's" and "gna's" though.
2nd Verse - Good.
2nd Chorus - Real good. Until it's not. He starts going flat (or sharp?) at the end. But honestly it sounded pretty good still. It's not enough to ruin what's been a pretty good performance.
6. About to Crash - Fair
First verse - Eh... He kinda sounds like he's barking to stay in key. He glissandos up to the note in a way that feels off at first, too. He's getting it, but it's not pretty.
Chorus - Fine. Nothing really to say.
Overall, I think it's a fair performance. Not pretty, but serviceable.
7. Losing Time - Poor/Fair
First verse - Good. Seems to be right in pocket for him.
Chorus - We've already talked about it, and it's not good.
Post-Chorus Thing - Ditto.
"Grand Finale" - He alternates between sounding very pitchy and very damn good. It's very interesting. Sometimes he sounds like classic James, and other times he totally loses himself, spiralling down... lmao. IDK. Fair, I guess? The crowd seem happy with him so maybe it was alright sounding in person.
8. Pull Me Under - Fair/Good
First verse - Good!
"This world is..." - Good!
"Watch the Sparrow Falling" Onward - Sounds weird but the replacement melody works out by the end.
"This world is...." - Pretty good!
Chorus - Pushing a bit sharp but honestly not too awful to listen to.
2nd Verse - Fair. He just kinda screeches instead of the high note he can't hit. I think it actually kinda works.
He's gonna hurt his voice more doing too much of this!
2nd Chorus - Same as the first.
Final chorus - Same, basically, maybe starting to feel more strained here than elsewhere.
It's a lot better than Caught in a Web, that's for sure. I'd say most of it is actually pretty dang good, with moments where it goes out.
9. The Count - Very Good/Great
First verse - Good.
"Get into my car" - some pitchiness but nothing too bad.
2nd verse - Good.
"Let me Introduce" - Good.
Chorus - Good. He does a "young sing now" for the "I" and I can't hear the audience.
3rd verse/prechorus - Good.
2nd Chorus - Good. A little pitchiness here and there but I don't think it's ruining anything.
Outro Verse - Great. Hey he sounds really good when the volume is lower and you can hear his full voice!
OV2 - Same.
"Now wait a minute man" - Good. He doesn't his all the notes but he kinda glissandos to replacement notes in a way that doesn't sound bad.
Overall, a solid performance of a classic. Great way to end the set on a high note.
10. TSCO - Fair.
James Part - Very Good. Right in pocket, like Solitary Shell and TCOT
Devin - Sounds great, obviously.
"Safe in the Light" - Seems to be a bit off at first, but kinda gets his footing toward end.
James and Devin duet the end, so it's it's hard to tell.
Overall, I think James has an alright night. Nothing is as bad as the very specific clip that got shared here. There is "some" stuff that is not great, "some" stuff that is clearly a miss, and mostly a lot of stuff that sounds... well... exactly what you'd expect.
Is he struggling? Sounds like it to me. He's struggling with high notes, across the board. Yet, sometimes he nails it. It does not seem to be a power issue, but maybe one of control and/or hearing. I found myself wondering, at various times, if he could properly hear himself. I wonder if his problems might improve if the band were to turn down a notch. He seems like he still has all the tools in his toolkit, and every time the band were quieter he nailed it.
I would like to hear a soundboard recording of one of these shows because honestly the setlist is great and I do think maybe James would sound a bit better - pitchiness or whatever - when it's not just the thinnest frequency of his voice trying to pierce through a mush.