Just judging by its reception on this forum, I’d agree with Our New World. The more time goes on, the more positive I am about The Astonishing in general, but I still don’t see Our New World as the sort of smash-hit, anthemic single that-would-be-on-the-radio-in-a-better-time. It’s a song with a role to play on the album and in the story, and it does so well, but I don’t know that I would rank it above the middle of the album.