I think you guys are all high. The double decker Vector/Virus is one of the best double albums I have ever heard and I don't understand why it's not regarded a modern classic of the genre
Well, first off, it's not a double album (sorry, it isn't), and second, the songwriting overall is far below the level of not only their first four albums, but of the best the genre has to offer.
So are Automata 1 and 2 by BTBAM completely separate albums, or two parts of a double album?
Because I honestly see absolutely zero difference between the two Automata albums and V/V
I'm not sure WHAT to think because even though Ayreon released both The Dream Sequencer AND Flight Of The Migrator simultaneously, they're still counted as the 4th and 5th albums, despite being two parts of the Universal Migrator. I personally consider both parts of a double album and then count The Human Equation as the fifth Ayreon album, but most places consider that the sixth one, so who knows anymore. Both albums were later re-released as a double album. I think the fact that they were written and released simultaneously helps the argument of calling them a double, but that's just me.
-Marc.
For me, the distinction of Double and Single album only relates to the album contracts musicians have with their labels. Releasing two separate albums of the same single concept, possibly counts as two albums being done under the contract. I see it as a way to handle the legal logistics and all that.
For me, the band releasing one single concept separately doesn't matter as the main focus is on the concept. So therefore for me, Virus and Vector are one concept released in two separate discs.
I liked the way they informed us the next release after Vector was going to be a compliment to it, by showing us through Social Media, pictures of Ketchup and Mustard, like saying "We got Ketchup, what compliments it?....Mustard."
I personally enjoy the albums and the story. The music compliments the story and enhances that mood of the type of story it is about. The music makes it feel as if you are the patient being experimented on by "The Good Doctor".
When I listen to concept albums, I do not treat them as normal albums with a collection of unrelated songs. I see them as a unit that when analyzed, needs to include what the concept is about, how the music is telling the story and also the lyrics, does the music progress the story or enhance the mood. This is a big reason I can enjoy Arjen and his cheese in Ayreon, because Ayreon is a big sci-fi concept and world he created, and the music being cheesy fits that concept of sci-fi in the vein of his favorite sci-fi series, Star Trek.