OK guys.....................today is a "DT" day in this thread. Feel free to discuss the new "single" from DT in addition to the normal stuff. That way we can follow a conversation on it without having to read 20 pages at a time ..
What do you guys think of it? I'll refer to a few posts relevant to my opinion
They focus on the story first and foremost, so the songs will be most likely be shorter in order to convey a part of the story, and with repating themes throughout like you'll hear in a movie score. The songs will be standalone, but yet be telling a whole story, and be designed to be played as a whole.
Sounds more like "classic" DT. If the whole album has this vibe - it will be the sound i've been missing since Octavarium.
Ok song. Sounds like it's a transitional song. Not like a segue or anything. More of a filler to keep the story going.
Exactly my thoughts too. I don't think it's fair to really judge it as it will probably work a lot better in the context of the album.
I don't mind it, but only listened to it once, and don't really have much of an urge to repeat it. I'd rather wait for the full album. I get a heavy SDOIT, About to Crash vibe too. The instrumental was really cool though. Looking forward to the whole concept.
These posts have me a bit worried in terms of my taste as I generally don't like albums "that need to be listened to from start to finish" and where "the music is a score for the story" - I just find the songs generally have no staying power and the lyrics become the focus , even though I don't want them to. With a few brilliant exceptions where the songs are also standouts - Mindcrime, streets, Crimson Idol. And I'm not all that fussed about Octavarium
I think I like the new song about as much as the better songs on SFAM (not saying much for me but promising I suppose) , but if this is the "single" (presumably chosen for being one of the more memorable pieces as a unit) then this is likely to be a more "theatrical" production and I'm not a fan of traditional theatre or "album long stories with a score".
In summary ............it sounds like it might be the sort of concept album format that I don't like , but the new song sounds about as good as it gets for me within that format. So I'm open minded, hoping to be astonished, but concerned. And the production seems to be an improvement , so that's good.
I'm still a bit iffy on this concept too - as someone posted elsewhere the other day "it sounds like something a 15 year old gamer would get a boner over"
Maybe that explains the changed demographic around these parts lately