Nothing will top the trinity of Facts, Photo, and Trans for me. They captured such a vibe on those records that hasn't quite been there since. I really liked Kintsugi quite a bit. It's easily my favorite since Transatlanticism. The new one is good, but it didn't have much staying power after the first few weeks. I felt like I heard it all before and while nothing is remotely bad, it's the first time it sounded like a band just going through the motions. Your Hurricane and Northern Lights are my favorites.
Narrow Stairs has a few throwaway tracks like Talking Bird, You Can Do Better, and Pity And Fear, and I wasn't a fan of the singles either (Possess and Grapevine Fires which is their most overrated song by far IMO) so I rank that one at the bottom. I think I'm the only one who loves Your New Twin Sized Bed and Bixby Canyon Bridge is an incredible song too. I liked Codes And Keys quite a bit, so it sucks that Ben is not a fan. They have a strong discography overall, but I think they've taken this mellow/semi-electronic style they've been doing for the past few albums to its furthest point and they need to reinvent themselves a bit on the next one.