Scarsick isn't a bad CD, it's just well below PoS standards, and this coming from a guy who loves Be. Musically it's not bad at all, but lyrically....it's really childish for the most part with some notable exceptions.
RS1 has some good stuff. I really like What She Means to Me, Of Dust, Sisters, Innocence, Road Salt, Tell Me You Don't Know, and Where it Hurts, with some others being...okay, But even those songs aren't up to PoS standards.
RS2 has some good stuff as well, I like it's darker tone. Healing Now, To The Shoreline, 1979, Of Salt, The Deeper Cut, Mortar Grind, Through the Distance and Physics are all very good songs.
However, maybe it's the really terrible production (I know it was intentional, but I have a lot of thoughts on that) and the addition of some really weak songs that drag it down to the bottom for me.