I played Hellfire Club at work today. Not too loud obviously, but I'll try and compare the discs a little more closely. I have basically written Edguy off. I like a band with a sense of humor, but it really started to unbalance the talent in this band.
What's the best Avantasia to get? I'm leaning towards Scarecrow. I WILL check them out soon. My birthday is next week, so I will score one Avantasia CD, I promise!