Neal Morse (from Morsefest this year).
I know what you mean, regarding Floyd. 15 studio albums and I would say I only truly love 5 of them (Dark Side, WYWH, Animals, The Wall and The Division Bell), and from the first 7 studio albums combined, there are probably only 7-8 songs I would say are Floyd songs I cannot live without. All of of my other top tier favorite bands have much higher levels of consistent greatness. But what works in Floyd's favor is how good those great albums. Their best three albums (Dark Side, WYWH and The Wall) would likely all make my all-time top 10.