I don't know if this is actually controversial, but Score might be one of the best live albums ever made. At least top Rock/Metal albums ever made, that's for sure
I own the DVD but not the CD of Score. The part with the orchestra is AWESOME, and that's as long as a lot of bands' full concerts. "The Score So Far" is a really good documentary, and it's cool to have the Octavarium animation.
The rest of of, however, is very "meh" (at best).
The Root of All Evil is a good song and show opener.
IWBY is probably the worst song on 8VM
Another Won is fine for what it is.
UAGM is my least favorite or second least favorite song on I&W.
Innocence Faded is my least or second least favorite song on Awake.
Raise the Knife is a bleh song that didn't make the cut for a bottom 2-3 DT album.
TSCO is a good live song, but it's way better in the context of the full SFAM show that we have on LSFNY.
And the bonus songs aren't any better.
If UAGM isn't my least favorite song on I&W, Another Day is.
The Great Debate is a bottom 5 DT song.
Honor Thy Father is the worst song on TOT by a pretty wide margin.
Given the structure of the part of the set without the orchestra, they would have been hard-pressed to put together a set that I liked less. Fortunately, everything else on the DVD makes it great in spite of that.