I'm kind of surprised to see One Day Remains ranked so low, it's my favorite AB by a wide, wide margin.
Genuinely curious what brings the album down to the bottom for you guys?
"Bottom" is relative. It's my least favorite, but I still love it. In fact, I'd say that the mix and production on that album is my favorite in the AB catalog. But it is my least favorite because the band had not yet realized Myles Kennedy was an incredible guitarist. It was written musically by Tremonti, with some tracks earmarked for the next Creed album. And as such, it's a record written to be played by one guitarist. It wasn't until Blackbird where the band musically made its blueprint, with Myles being an active guitar player, not just live, but his playing on the record. If you watch them live, Myles typically doesn't play guitar on stuff from the record, unless it is a slower number like Burn it Down or In Loving Memory. All the heavy or epic tracks, he's just singing. Still cool, but not what AB ultimately became once Mark and the band realized what a phenomenal player Myles was, and incorporated his playing style to make AB what it is from Blackbird through today.
re: The future
The posts from yesterday, my wife and I talked about AB a bunch last night, and she just steadfastly said "they need to get away from Elvis." She said, and I agree, that she clearly feels like there is a masterpiece from AB that is yet to come out, and we discussed at length the fact that AB play it safe and check boxes when making a record. Mrs. Samsara suggested David Bottrill, due to all the great records he's done, specifically a favorite of ours, Mastodon's Hushed and Grim.
Here's the thing - Walk the Sky is one of my least favorite AB records, but it is also one of the ones I respect the most, because the band didn't play it safe - they experimented. Pawns & Kings, while my second favorite AB record (despite having two of my least favorite AB songs in Season of Promise and Holiday), is very much a "play it safe" album. In some ways, Walk the Sky was too...making sure boxes were checked with "Wouldn't You Rather" and "Dying Light" (which I love, but they specifically went back to write those feeling they needed those "type of" songs to finish the album.
AB needs to stop being this afterthought by Myles and Mark. Both of them love their solo bands. They devote a lot of time and energy to them. They also like playing for bigger crowds (Slash for Myles, Creed for Mark). And that's fine. But they are spread so thin, AB has gone from Mark and Myles each coming up with lots of different parts to songs, and then sitting together and creating songs, to each of them writing songs in a vacuum by themselves, and then coming together and picking which ones they all like for an AB record. It's not organic. It's not challenging. It has gotten very stale.
I think AB would be very well served by Myles and Mark setting aside a couple months for songwriting and preproduction next time out. Just get in a room and write together and take chances. Then get a new production team. Do something DIFFERENT. Because while I love AB, and I love their songs, Mrs. Samsara is right - I always hear that masterpiece that they've yet to do. You hear brilliance in many of their epics. And in some of the more intense, straight forward metal/hard rock cuts (Isolation, Show Me a Leader, Ties That Bind, etc.). But there is always SOMETHING that interrupts an idea.
For example, doing Pawns and Kings, Myles has said things in the press how after the first five tracks, with the songs very intense, and sorta deep emotionally, they wanted "Holiday" to break it up, not be so serious. Well, WHY THE HELL do you feel the need to do that? There's no need. AB is really good at the intense, serious vibe. Embrace it. Don't feel a need to put some sort of poppy chorus middle of the album cut in there. Embrace what you're good at.
They did the same thing after "Fable." Season of Promise. Poppy chorus, not so intense. And then after that, they get dark and proggy with Last Man Standing and the title track. All of that is because the band felt the need to "check the boxes" at two specific points on the record. That's stupid, honestly. Regardless of whether a fan likes those two songs or not (I know I am in the minority in that I don't like them), the STYLE of the songs was not needed. Not with the type of material that was throughout Pawns and Kings. EMBRACE the direction. Don't feel a need (which I am sure was in part pushed by Elvis Baskette) to check boxes because of expectation.
I want Alter Bridge to focus on Alter Bridge. Get in a room, take chances, write together like you did from Blackbird through The Last Hero. And once you have the songs and a clear vision, then get a production team that will challenge you, not that you are comfortable with. That's my desire and hope for AB moving forward.
For me, one of the greatest bands over the last 20 years, that for whatever reason, tends to sometimes get in its own way. Here's hoping next time out is their "Mindcrime."