If we remove Images & Words and Awake, what album has your favorite LaBrie work?

[bosk1]

I loved the idea of The Astonishing. To the point that I defended it for a long time against its detractors.

But over time, I began to admit that it was a flawed execution of an incredible idea.

But in spite of all its flaws, James is not one of them. The Astonishing is really a highlight for James. He brings it all to the table on every track.

TA is such a frustrating album for me, because not only is it a really good idea, but there's a certain passion to it. James and Jordan in particular are particularly strong on the album. But I will always double down that the album feels unfinished somehow.

Yup, great take.  I agree completely. 

As for the question, I think he's been great on every album, really.  If we are talking about album performances, it's hard to choose.  My top 4 are probably Scenes, Six Degrees, The Astonishing, and Parasomnia.  Which is "best" depends on when you ask.