DT 1-2 punch, Part II

[ariich]

Not sure how an album of 5 tracks can have a "lot" of filler

And The Great Debate is amazing.

Well if you look at it like that, then yeah, but if you go beyond "lol only 5 tracks" there's obviously a shit ton of music in those 5 tracks. And I find a lot of it passable.

That doesn't make it filler though. Filler isn't the same thing as "stuff I don't like".

[Dark Castle]

Me saying it's filler is just my opinion, which you obviously don't have to agree with. And it's not that I dislike it, I just don't feel like a lot of it was necessary.

[Shadow Ninja 2.0]

Not sure how an album of 5 tracks can have a "lot" of filler

And The Great Debate is amazing.

Well if you look at it like that, then yeah, but if you go beyond "lol only 5 tracks" there's obviously a shit ton of music in those 5 tracks. And I find a lot of it passable.

That doesn't make it filler though. Filler isn't the same thing as "stuff I don't like".

Well, there's no real way to determine what's actually "filler" unless you're part of the band that wrote it. So I guess "filler" is kind of up for interpretation.

I don't think SDOIT has filler, though.

[KevShmev]

Filler isn't the same thing as "stuff I don't like".

Good luck convincing a lot of people of that.  I have been beating that same drum for forever. 

[Obfuscation]

SFAM/SDOIT

[AngelBack]

I would have to go with SFAM and SDOIT.  On any given day I would list I&W, SFAM, and SDOIT as my top three DT albums.  Where each album falls in my top three depends on the day, so all three are considered great in my mind.  Awake does fall lower in my rankings, and therefore pulls the I&W/Awake pairing below the SFAM/SDOIT pairing.

Pretty much this.

[Octavarious]

SFAM and SDOIT cannot be beat. The musicianship, concepts, variety, production quality, hooks, creativity all go to SFAM and SDOIT. In my book it isn't close.

-Tof

This.

[Dirty30]

I cut my DT teeth with SFAM... SDOIT (the song, more than the album) is my personal holy grail, thus elevating the album into the stratosphere. Sorry I&W and Awake... You're both great, but you're just not that high in my book.

[Evermind]

Would've voted for SFAM/SDOIT if not for the title track of the latter.

I&W and Awake.

[hefdaddy42]

I&W and Awake.  I have them ranked 1 & 2.

But I have SFAM & 6DOIT ranked 3 & 4, so I can't really go wrong here.

[King Postwhore]

SFAM & 6DOIT

[Theme Dreater]

I love all four albums, but I hold I&W, Awake, and SFAM on a slightly higher level than SDOIT. My vote goes to the first choice.

[Invisible]

This is tough... My personal ranking is Awake, FII(would be higher and nº1 with the B Sides), SDOIT, I&W, Scenes. I guess I'll have to go with I&W/Awake, but it's an extremely tough choice. The best of KM vs. the best of JR, I might as well choose both any day, if you ask me tomorow I'll probably chose the other option, and so forth .