DT Song Wars XVI

[KevShmev]

Featuring songs this time from Scenes from a Memory, Octavarium and the self-titled album.

[Lucien]

Fatal Tragedy, These Walls, Illumination Theory, easily.

[BlobVanDam]

Fatal Tragedy, These Walls & Illumination Theory.

TSCO/PA/STR and SDV/8V/TLG were also possibilities for me.

[Unlegit]

FT, TW, and IT. Definitely the best trio here.

[425]

Strange Deja-Vu, Octavarium and The Looking Glass. Octavarium on its own is practically strong enough to carry this trio against any of its competition, and the fact that SDV is an incredibly great song and TLG is fantastic as well makes this trio the obvious choice for me.

[The Letter M]

FT/TW/IT

I love FT and TW is pretty good. And of course, I looooove IT, so it was nearly a no-brainer.

-Marc.

[Shadow Ninja 2.0]

Strange Deja Vu, Octavarium, and The Looking Glass, mainly based on the strength of Octavarium, though I like the other songs.

[?]

FF, TROAE, AFTR

[Jaffa]

Strange Deja Vu, Octavarium, and The Looking Glass. 

[Rattlehead]

Strange Deja Vu, Octavarium, and The Looking Glass.

[Outcrier]

Strange Deja Vu, Octavarium & The Looking Glass.

[wolfking]

Fatal Tragedy, These Walls, Illumination Theory, easily.

[Polarbear]

The Spirit Carries On, Panic Attack & Surrender to Reason.
None of these songs are masterpieces or disasters, but its the overall strongest trio.

[hefdaddy42]

Fatal Tragedy, These Walls, Illumination Theory, easily.

This exactly.

[Evermind]

Home, Sacrificed Sons & The Bigger Picture for me.

[krands85]

This is the toughest choice for me from these new song wars polls. Once again made trickier due to the fact that my favourite track out of all these (Octavarium, my #3 DT track) is with TLG.

The first 4 options are all pretty good, but TW and AFTR drag down the 2nd and 4th a bit. Struggling to decide between the consistency of options 1 and 3 or the pull of IT in 3. I guess I'll go with Home, SS and TBP, though I could vote differently at another time.

[Ruba]

Finally Free, The Root of All Evil and Along for the Ride. The only option with three top 50-material songs.

[wasteland]

Finally, Root and Ride, but the Illumination Theory boat was about to win this one 

[CharlesPL]

Fatal Tragedy, These Walls & Illumination Theory

[jakepriest]

Home (my no. 1 from SFAM), Sacrificed Sons (no. 2 from Octavarium) and Bigger Picture

[GasparXR]

Option 4, but I could have picked Option 1.

[gmillerdrake]

Strange Deja Vu, Octavarium, and The Looking Glass.

This.

[Grizz]

Definitely 1, but 3 came the closest by far.

[Daso]

Went with SDV/8VM/TLG. SDV is one of the songs that I'm not fatigued off from SFaM, 8VM is Top 5 DT for me and TLG is Top 3 DT12. Could've voted for FT/TW/IT since both FT and IT hold similar places to the ones from their respective albums, but I couldn't stand listening to TW until the LaLP version, which has helped the song to grow on me (but I still don't like the 8VM version).

[mikeyd23]

FT, These Walls, IT