The Setlist Game! ~ Round 7 (Onno's Setlist)

[MajorMatt]

I'd love to see Status Seeker live, one of my favorites from WDADU. 

[YtseJamittaja]

I'd love to see Status Seeker live, one of my favorites from WDADU. 

Yeah, too bad that many of the fans don't like it...

[Setlist Scotty]

I'd love to see Status Seeker live, one of my favorites from WDADU. 

Not to brag, but I was fortunate enough to see them perform it on 2 occasions, and I gotta say that the version with the revised intro (as played in 1993) is much better IMO than the studio version (as played in 1988/89 and 2004).

[wasteland]

I'd love to see Status Seeker live, one of my favorites from WDADU. 

Not to brag, but I was fortunate enough to see them perform it on 2 occasions, and I gotta say that the version with the revised intro (as played in 1993) is much better IMO than the studio version (as played in 1988/89 and 2004).

So you saw them in '93 as well?

[Setlist Scotty]

I'd love to see Status Seeker live, one of my favorites from WDADU. 

Not to brag, but I was fortunate enough to see them perform it on 2 occasions, and I gotta say that the version with the revised intro (as played in 1993) is much better IMO than the studio version (as played in 1988/89 and 2004).

So you saw them in '93 as well?

Yup. The show at Summerfest (in Milwaukee) was my first time seeing them, tho I'd been a fan for 4 years at that point and had met them 5 months earlier at a "music clinic" (an instore appearance with a 45 minute Q&A, JP playing guitar and autograph session).

[JayOctavarium]

This is very off topic... but


sometimes I feel that I am too obsessive or too big of a fan of DT... then I come here and I realize that some of you are 10x as bad as me.

[wasteland]

I'd love to see Status Seeker live, one of my favorites from WDADU. 

Not to brag, but I was fortunate enough to see them perform it on 2 occasions, and I gotta say that the version with the revised intro (as played in 1993) is much better IMO than the studio version (as played in 1988/89 and 2004).

So you saw them in '93 as well?

Yup. The show at Summerfest (in Milwaukee) was my first time seeing them, tho I'd been a fan for 4 years at that point and had met them 5 months earlier at a "music clinic" (an instore appearance with a 45 minute Q&A, JP playing guitar and autograph session).

It's funny that you mentioned the Milwaukee show. I was listening it in my car just a couple of hours ago. 

[GasparXR]

Status Seeker is awesome! As for the alternate intro, I prefer the original, but I love the alternate ending, which is why I love the WDADRU version.

[Ruba]

I'd love to see Status Seeker live, one of my favorites from WDADU. 

Yeah, too bad that many of the fans don't like it...

True.

[Octavaripolis]

Metropolis Pt.1
Lines in the Sand
Home
Don't Look Past Me
The Root of All Evil
Take The Time
Mike Mangini Solo Spot
Another Hand / The Killing Hand
Wait for Sleep
Innocence Faded
Canadian Rap
Space-Dye Vest
Surrounded
Trial of Tears
Status Seeker
Blind Faith
Bridges in the Sky
Afterlife
Learning to Live '06
---------------------------
A Change of Seasons

[Hayden]

This is rapidly becoming a very retro setlist, I've noticed.

[Scorpion]

Except for BITS, the newest song is the Canadian Rap.

[robwebster]

You're very welcome. (But it's actually The Root of All Evil.)

Think it's because people are going for rarities - a song they've played in the last few tours is less of an exciting addition than one they haven't - but it is becoming a little bit of a snoozefest.

[dvargas]

whoever took a mind beside itself and put stream of consciousness instead ?

that borders on irresponsible.

[wasteland]

You're very welcome. (But it's actually The Root of All Evil.)

Think it's because people are going for rarities - a song they've played in the last few tours is less of an exciting addition than one they haven't - but it is becoming a little bit of a snoozefest.

Metropolis, ACOS, LTL, ToT and BITS in one set and it's a snoozefest? 

[robwebster]

You're very welcome. (But it's actually The Root of All Evil.)

Think it's because people are going for rarities - a song they've played in the last few tours is less of an exciting addition than one they haven't - but it is becoming a little bit of a snoozefest.

Metropolis, ACOS, LTL, ToT and BITS in one set and it's a snoozefest? 

God, yes! It's austere as hell! Space Dye Vest, Lines in the Sand, Trial of Tears, The Killing Hand, A Change of Seasons, Wait for Sleep - all good songs, well written, but where's the fun!?

I'm exaggerating. Take the Time's a good laugh, as is TROAE, and Don't Look Past Me, and Innocence Faded threatens to be, at points. But there's a very, very good reason songs like Constant Motion got so much live play.

[wasteland]

Yeah, to scare away fans like me  (bottom #1 DT song for me!)

[GasparXR]

Well, guys, this round has come to an end! The result setlist is very different from the first one! (I accidentally clicked post too early, was supposed to wait until midnight, oops )



Look at that! Only 4 songs remained from the original, and 2 of them are in different places. This of course means Octavaripolis is granted the honour of creating the first setlist of round 2! Whenever you're ready!

Everyone of course gets one turn this round, just like last round. Make sure to update the list of participants as you post.

https://i722.photobucket.com/albums/ww224/GasparXR/setlistround1_zpsb28625c4.png
------------
Final List of Participants:

GasparXR, Setlist Scotty, Morawintersoul, Cedar redaC, Pols Voice, Jonny108, Unlegit, JayOctavarium, Lolzeez, Ytsejamittaja, SomeoneLikeHim, cyberdrummer, wasteland, MajorMatt, dvargas, Dacling, Metrovarium, Ice9ine, Scorpion, ?, Hayden, JoeG, Ruba, Grinch, Elite, robwebster, Infinite Cactus, Octavaripolis

[Hayden]

Should we allow another user to post a setlist if it takes more than a day for the rightful successor to do so?

[wasteland]

Yeah, Octavariopolis hasn't really been much active as of late. If he forfeits, remember that I have asked first

[Hayden]

I'm interested in seeing your setlist anyway, haha.

[?]

If the new setlist will be one that has actually been played at some show, it should have lots of room for improvements, like this: https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/dream-theater/2005/beethovensaal-stuttgart-germany-4bd6d30e.html

I mean, This Dying Soul and Never Enough back to back?

[wasteland]

Well, if Gaspar is OK with it, I would start with this one:

Quebec City, March 26th, 2004

0.  Band history video (intro tape)
1.  As I Am
2.  This Dying Soul
3.  Under a Glass Moon
4.  Beyond This Life (w/ extended improv section)
5.  Hollow Years (w/ extended guitar solo)
6.  Another Hand/The Killing Hand
7.  Endless Sacrifice
8.  Trial of Tears
~~~intermission~~~
9.  New Millennium
10.  Caught in a Web (w/ drum solo w/ audience participation)
11.  Another Day
12.  guitar solo (w/ excerpts of Nothing Else Matters (Metallica) and Hourglass (LTE))
13.  Goodnight Kiss
14.  Solitary Shell
15.  Stream of Consciousness
16.  In the Name of God
~~~encore~~~
Dead Poets Society (intro tape)
A Change of Seasons:
17.  I The Crimson Sunrise
18.  II Innocence
19.  III Carpe Diem
20.  IV The Darkest of Winters
21.  V Another World
22.  VI The Inevitable Summer
23.  VII The Crimson Sunset

Round 2 - Partecipants
wasteland - started
JayOctavarium
cyberdrummer
?
Lolzeez
Unlegit
Cedar redaC
Elite
robwebster
Ruba
Scorpion
SomeoneLikeHim

[?]

^It wouldn't be hard to decide which song I want to kick out from that setlist

[JayOctavarium]

band history video (intro tape)
1.  As I Am
2.  This Dying Soul
3.  Under a Glass Moon
4.  Beyond This Life (w/ extended improv section)
5.  Hollow Years (w/ extended guitar solo)
6.  Another Hand/The Killing Hand
7.  Endless Sacrifice
8.  Trial of Tears
~~~intermission~~~
9.  New Millennium
10.  Caught in a Web (w/ drum solo w/ audience participation)
11.  Another Day
12.  guitar solo (w/ excerpts of Nothing Else Matters (Metallica) and Hourglass (LTE))
13.  Goodnight Kiss
14. Vacant
15.  Stream of Consciousness
16.  In the Name of God
~~~encore~~~
Dead Poets Society (intro tape)
A Change of Seasons:
17.  I The Crimson Sunrise
18.  II Innocence
19.  III Carpe Diem
20.  IV The Darkest of Winters
21.  V Another World
22.  VI The Inevitable Summer
23.  VII The Crimson Sunset









Now I'm happy


wasteland - started
JayOctavarium

[cyberdrummer]

1.  The Glass Prison
2.  This Dying Soul
3.  Under a Glass Moon
4.  Beyond This Life (w/ extended improv section)
5.  Hollow Years (w/ extended guitar solo)
6.  Another Hand/The Killing Hand
7.  Endless Sacrifice
8.  Trial of Tears
~~~intermission~~~
9.  New Millennium
10.  Caught in a Web (w/ drum solo w/ audience participation)
11.  Another Day
12.  guitar solo (w/ excerpts of Nothing Else Matters (Metallica) and Hourglass (LTE))
13.  Goodnight Kiss
14. Vacant
15.  Stream of Consciousness
16.  In the Name of God
~~~encore~~~
Dead Poets Society (intro tape)
17. A Change of Seasons


wasteland - started
JayOctavarium
cyberdrummer

[?]

So we started already? This setlist needs some ADTOE!

1.  The Glass Prison
2.  This Dying Soul
3.  Under a Glass Moon
4.  Beyond This Life (w/ extended improv section)
5.  Hollow Years (w/ extended guitar solo)
6.  Another Hand/The Killing Hand
7.  Endless Sacrifice
8.  Trial of Tears
~~~intermission~~~
9.  Bridges in the Sky
10.  Caught in a Web (w/ drum solo w/ audience participation)
11.  Another Day
12.  guitar solo (w/ excerpts of Nothing Else Matters (Metallica) and Hourglass (LTE))
13.  Goodnight Kiss
14. Vacant
15.  Stream of Consciousness
16.  In the Name of God
~~~encore~~~
Dead Poets Society (intro tape)
17. A Change of Seasons


wasteland - started
JayOctavarium
cyberdrummer
?

[JayOctavarium]

Yes!



There are 2 more tracks to be changed out and this would make for  the ultimate set for me

[cyberdrummer]

Endless Sacrifice and Another Day?

[JayOctavarium]

Hell no.


Beyond This Life and Goodnight Kiss


and maybe change Hollow Years to the '09 version

I'd kill for that setlist.

[wasteland]

Endless Sacrifice and Another Day?

This Dying Soul!

But did starting count as a move from me?

[MoraWintersoul]

Oh God I would barely touch that. One of the rare things I'd do to it is stick SDV somewhere but it would be out of place in any place I'd like to replace. Can I say place one more time? PLACE.

[JayOctavarium]

PLACE

[Lolzeez]

1.  The Glass Prison
2.  This Dying Soul
3.  Under a Glass Moon
4.  Beyond This Life (w/ extended improv section)
5.  Hollow Years (w/ extended guitar solo)
6.  Another Hand/The Killing Hand
7.  Endless Sacrifice
8.  Trial of Tears
~~~intermission~~~
9.  Bridges in the Sky
10.  Caught in a Web (w/ drum solo w/ audience participation)
11.  Another Day
12.  guitar solo (w/ excerpts of Nothing Else Matters (Metallica) and Hourglass (LTE))
13.  Goodnight Kiss
14. Vacant
15.  Stream of Consciousness
16.  Learning To Live
~~~encore~~~
Dead Poets Society (intro tape)
17. A Change of Seasons

wasteland - started
JayOctavarium
cyberdrummer
?
Lolzeez

[?]

Oh God I would barely touch that.

Add Speak to Me in there? It wasn't in the previous setlist at any point.