Which album has the most 9+/10 songs?

[ddtonfire]

Which album has the most songs you would give 9 or 10 stars out of 10? This is total songs, not which album has the greatest percentage of its songs 9+/10. It is certainly possible that it might not necessarily end up being your "favorite," album, since, as albums are concerned, the sum of the parts do not singularly make up the whole.

For me, it's Six Degrees simply because I'm counting each movement as a separate track (which, for the purposes of this poll, you should, too). If that weren't the case, it would be ADToE, but probably because it still has that new album smell. And this is interesting because Awake's my favorite album!

[Liberation]

Scenes From a Memory. The only song there I'd give less than 9 is The Dance of Eternity (which is 7 or so).

[FlyingBIZKIT]

WDADU - Afterlife, The Killing Hand, Only A Matter Of Time
I&W - Learning To Live, Metropolis, Wait For Sleep, Surrounded, Take The Time
Awake - A Mind Beside Itself, The Mirror, Lifting Shadows, Scarred, Space-Dye Vest
FII - Lines In The Sand, Peruvian Skies, New Millennium, Trial Of Tears, Hell's Kitchen
SFAM - Regression/Overture 1928/Strange Deja Vu, Fatal Tragedy, Beyond This Life, One Last Time, FF
SDOIT - ALL OF EM
TOT - Vacant, This Dying Soul, In The Name Of God
8VM - Octavarium, Sacrificed Sons, The Root Of All Evil
SC - Repentance
BCSL - The Count Of Tuscany, A Nightmare To Remember, The Best Of Times
ADTOE - Lost Not Forgotten, This Is The Life, Bridges In The Sky, Breaking All Illusions, Beneath The Surface

SDOIT, because 100% is a 10

[Liberation]

Well, doing it like this... (The 100% certain 10s are underlined)

When Dream and Day Unite - A Fortune in Lies
Images & Words - Pull Me Under, Wait for Sleep, Learning to Live
Awake - Voices, The Mirror, Space-Dye Vest
Falling Into Infinity - Peruvian Skies, Trial of Tears
Scenes From a Memory - EVERYTHING except The Dance of Eternity
Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence - The Great Debate, Disappear, About to Crash, The Test That Stumped Them All, Losing Time/Grand Finale (I used to absolutely love The Glass Prison but now I'm uncertain)
Train of Thought - This Dying Soul, Vacant, In The Name of God
Octavarium - The Root of All Evil, Sacrificed Sons, Octavarium
Systematic Chaos - Repentance, The Ministry of Lost Souls, In The Presence of Enemies Pt. 2
Black Clouds & Silver Linings - A Night Night Nightmare to Remember, The Shattered Fortess, The Count of Tuscany
A Dramatic Turn of Events - I think most songs... it's a very, very consistent album, however, Outcry

[ddtonfire]

Interesting... I suppose I'll list them too:
WDADU - None
IaW - Pull Me Under, Met. Pt. I, UAGM, LTL
Awake - The Mirror, Scarred, Space Dye Vest
FII - Hell's Kitchen
SFAM - Overture 1928, Finally Free
6DOiT - Glass Prison, Blind Faith, Disappear, Six Degrees (specifically About to Crash, Goodnight Kiss, Solitary Shell, and Losing Time/Grand Finale)
ToT - Honor Thy Father, ItNoG
8va - These Walls, 8va
SC - ItPoE, pt. I, Forsaken
BC&SL - ANtR, TCoT
ADToE - LNF, BitS, Outcry, BAI, BtS

[reza_122]

WDADU -> YtseJam, Afterlife
IAW       -> Metropolis, Another Day
Awake   -> Erotomania, The Silent Man
FII         -> Hell's Kitchen, LInes In The Sand
SFAM     -> All songs, except Home
SDoIT    -> The Glass Prison, Blind Faith, SDoIT
ToT        -> This Dying Soul, Honor Thy Father, SoC, In The Name of God
8vm       -> The Root of All Evil, I Walk Beside You, Sacrificed Sons, 8vm
SC          -> Constant Motion, The Dark Eternal Night, The Ministry of Lost Souls
BC&SL   -> The Shattered Fortress, Wither, The Best of Times
ADToE   -> On The Backs of Angels, Outcry, Breaking All Illusions

[j]

Images and Words, by far.

I like Awake just as much, or arguably more, but it would probably be fairly low if I ranked the albums like this.

-J

[BlobVanDam]

It was between IaW and SDOIT to me, but i went with SDOIT. SFAM is my 2nd favourite DT album, but it only has maybe 1 9/10 song (TSCO).

WDADU - lol. No.
IaW - Another Day, TTT, Metropolis, UAGM, the rest are really close behind though.
Awake - Voices, The Silent Man
FII - Hollow Years, LITS, ToT
SFAM - TSCO
SDOIT - TGP, BF, Misunderstood, Disappear, SDOIT
ToT - As I Am, Vacant, ITNOG
Octavarium - TW, PA, Octavarium
SC - CM, TDEN (I'd give a lot of the rest 8 or 8.5)
BCASL - ANTR, TCOT
ADTOE - Not sure if any can quite nudge to a 9 yet, although TITL, LNF and BITS might eventually.

[Ħ]

If SDOIT is counted as separate tracks, then EASILY that.  But if not, then it's really tricky.

[setrataeso]

SDOIT. All the songs save for Misunderstood are fantastic.

[theseoafs]

6DOIT is the clear winner here.

[hefdaddy42]

I think you probably need to state how 6DOIT should be counted for the purposes of this thread.  If some people count it as one, and some people count it as eight, then your results could be wildly skewed.

But I&W for me.

[ddtonfire]

I did say how I counted it in the OP.

[snapple]

I voted Awake because it is my favorite album of Dream Theater's. It is easily in my top 2 albums ever.

[hefdaddy42]

I did say how I counted it in the OP.

You needed to tell people how THEY should count it.

[snapple]

Wdadu has no 9/10's on it?

The Killing Hand? Only A Matter of Time? A Fortune in Lies? Afterlife?

[Jarzombek]

Images and Words

[RuRoRul]

Train Of Thought

[OsMosis2259]

Images and Words