Update...
Ironically, I got my hands on English Settlement last night and I am loving that so far. The back half has a few songs I can do without, but the first half is money and I do like some of the later tracks like Fly on the Wall. I listened to it a lot today at work on the ear buds and it just got better and better. I love the sound of the bass guitar on this record. This could be the start of a new band obsession for me...
3 1/2 months later, I am still listening to XTC probably 50-60% of the time I have any music playing. Tremendous band.
And I was slightly off below when I said:
I've checked out a little more XTC and I can tell this will be a very hit or miss band for me. I love English Settlement, but Mummer seems a little spotty; some really good songs and some blah songs. And I tried Drums and Wires, but that one annoyed the shit out of me and I gave up halfway through. I think going for the later artier stuff is the way to go, rather than going backwards for the more punk stuff, since punk is not my bag.
The only misses are the first three albums, which have a collective 6-7 songs I have any use for. After that:
Black Sea - outstanding!
English Settlement - magnificent!
Mummer - very good
The Big Express - inconsistent, but still good
25 O'Clock - trippy and awesome!
Skylarking - a masterpiece
Psonic Psunsport - tremendous!
Oranges and Lemons - very good
Nonsuch - very good
Apple Venus, Part 1 - outstanding!
Wasp Star - inconsistent, but still pretty good
That is 9 major keepers out of 14. And they have quite a few great b-sides I have been digging into as well. I will be buying the Steven Wilson 5.1 releases of their work very soon.
The plan next is to try The Smiths or The Cure...