This is to me the "other" classic album of Helloween.
Sure, the classic line-up is the Keepers one, but Deris / Weikath / Grosskopf / Grapow / Kusch for me is the second classic line-up of Helloween, that produced excellent albums and this is the best. A wonderful record.
I'll go for A Million to One just 'cause I like the silliness of Anything my Mama don't Like, but I guess that song is first to go.