The TAC Roulette V.2..Steaming Results!

[twosuitsluke]

I think 4 is pretty good, actually.

Not considering two of those had already said what they were sending 

I feel 100% on Tomislav
Maybe swap around home and Train? I know they both love GiaA
The Ocean and DMM are throwing me out. If Parama and Sacul hadn't given the game away I'd have guessed they sent these two, respectively

[TAC]

I think 4 is pretty good, actually.

Not considering two of those had already said what they were sending 

True. 


Still, 2 out of 7...

[Crow]

goddammit now i have to resend my round 6, thanks lordcost or whoever. ugh
and i know you did the worst possible thing by sending an instrumental track off pelagial which means it's massively inferior to the actual version of the song. i listened to the instrumental disc once and never again because it just, loses so goddamn much

[TAC]

Parama, this is the second round (out of 4) that's I've allowed two songs from the same band. I have no problem with you staying with The Ocean track. That is, unless someone sends the same track.

[Crow]

if someone else sends the track i sent that's okay 'cause then i can just send you something else i wanted to send & let someone else take the fall with that one 

[Shadow Ninja 2.0]

Pelagial + vocals is brilliant, but the instrumental version is still fantastic. As well as presumably better suited to people who don't care for harsh vocals.

[TAC]

*raises hand*

[The Silent Cody]

Russian Circles
David Maxim Micic
God Is An Astronaut
Gordian Knot
The Ocean
Caspian
Kyuss
Russian Circles
Thank You Scientist

Pretty sure I could guess who sent what and get it 90% right.

Go!!

Ok,
(...)
Gordian Knot - The Silent Cody
(...)

Ok, 90% may have been optimistic 

Nope 
I heard about the band but I NEVER heard the band

[LordCost]

goddammit now i have to resend my round 6, thanks lordcost or whoever. ugh
and i know you did the worst possible thing by sending an instrumental track off pelagial which means it's massively inferior to the actual version of the song. i listened to the instrumental disc once and never again because it just, loses so goddamn much

It's my default idea for an instrumental round. I did the same for your roulette and you liked the song 
Maybe Tac it's one of the few people who could prefer the instrumental disc because of growls.

[wolfking]

Gordian Knot?!  Fucking win!  If I were to send Gordian Knot, off the top of my head, I'd send Rivers Dancing or maybe Shaman's Whisper.

[home]

God is an Astronaut - Home
Caspian - Train

These should probably be swapped

I did consider sending GiaA tho 

[TAC]

Gordian Knot?!  Fucking win!  If I were to send Gordian Knot, off the top of my head, I'd send Rivers Dancing or maybe Shaman's Whisper.

One of those is correct.

[TAC]

Wow, this round has been by far the best. Two listens in and I'm really enjoying this.




Announcement!

Two things:

1. Because the last week at work was such a bitch, I just started listening today. Results for this round will not be posted until Monday afternoon. That said, the next round is an open round, so please try and have those in by Monday evening. I plan on downloading all of the tracks either Monday or Tuesday morning. That should get me back on track schedulewise.


2. Round 7 is an Accoustic Round. Just to clarify, it can be a track set to piano or keyboards too. Just looking for something soft. But not necessarily slow. It can include full band, but it must be very understated.

[Crow]

I kinda regret sending the Hirsch Effekt for round 3 becsuse they have a great acoustic EP but also I wanted to send one of their best so whatever

Hardest round for me to find something for though, for sure
edit: 90% sure i'm gonna end up with something that has no guitar at all but hey it's allowed apparently 

[wolfking]

Gordian Knot?!  Fucking win!  If I were to send Gordian Knot, off the top of my head, I'd send Rivers Dancing or maybe Shaman's Whisper.

One of those is correct.

Without really knowing Cody's thoughts on this band, just knowing the band myself, I could have bet it would be one of those two.  Flip of a coin which one, both very different. 

[TAC]

It wasn't Cody.




So two people sent Russian Circles. Just saying that one of the tracks is clearly better than the other. One will be tied for the top score in the round, and the other might be tied for the worst.

[Crow]

aww yeah tied for worst with rushin' circles

[TAC]

aww yeah tied for worst with rushin' circles

Well, there's still 4 more rounds to make it up.

[Crow]

i am seriously considering sending a death metal epic in round 8

[TAC]

i am seriously considering sending a death metal epic in round 8

It's the reason I'm having this roulette!

[TAC]

Just scratched out the write-ups. Will likely end up posting ahead of schedule. Likely tonight.

But anyway, here are the scores:

9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
8.5
8.0
8.0
7.5
7.5

[Crow]

there's the expected 7.5

[TAC]

there's the expected 7.5

I will say that your submission um..stood out.

[jingle.boy]

Just scratched out the write-ups. Will likely end up posting ahead of schedule. Likely tonight.

But anyway, here are the scores:

9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
8.5
8.0
8.0
7.5
7.5

Man you're loose with your scoring.

[wolfking]

Just scratched out the write-ups. Will likely end up posting ahead of schedule. Likely tonight.

But anyway, here are the scores:

9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
8.5
8.0
8.0
7.5
7.5

Tim, your verging on mr.com style scoring now.

[Crow]

it's better than scar-style scoring for sure

[twosuitsluke]

it's better than scar-style scoring for sure

Average score=10/10

[wolfking]

it's better than scar-style scoring for sure

Seriously, WTF?

[Crow]

scar's roulette was a very "special" occurrence

[TAC]

Just scratched out the write-ups. Will likely end up posting ahead of schedule. Likely tonight.

But anyway, here are the scores:

9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
8.5
8.0
8.0
7.5
7.5

Tim, your verging on mr.com style scoring now.

What can I say? It was a "solid" round!

[jingle.boy]

[Crow]

i see results in the thread title........ but where are they

[Sacul]

but where are they

[Cool Chris]

This makes me feel sad handing out 1s and 2s in my roulette.

[LordCost]

it's better than scar-style scoring for sure

Average score=10/10

The best thing is the change of meter the next round. 3/10 to Parama and lots of 6s and 7s