The Symphony X Survivor 2017 - The Damnation Game Round 6

[Scar]

Dressed to Kill - 1
The Edge of Forever - 5
Whispers - 4
A Winter's Dream - Prelude (Part I) - 1

The Edge of Forever is forever out! NEXT!

[IDontNotDoThings]

#1.
#2.
#3.
#4. The Damnation Game
#5. The Edge Of Forever
#6. The Haunting
#7. A Winter's Dream I
#8. Secrets
#9. Savage Curtain

[Randaran]

What the hell? I did not see that coming

Dressed to Kill

1. The Edge of Forever
2.
3.
4.
5. Dressed to Kill
6. The Haunting
7. Secrets
8. Savage Curtain
9. Winter's Dream I

[ToT-147]

Wow.. I don't like TEoF so much, but I thougth it was at least making it to the finals..

Anyways.. Whispers ( I can't not think of Sense8's character now that I'm writting this name )..

[MirrorMask]

One of the best songs SX ever released is eliminated? what the bloody hell?!?!

I'll take it out on Winter's Dream.

[jjrock88]

I figured Edge of Forever had a chance to go quite far in the finals

Whispers

[wolfking]

What the fuck?

Whispers.

[LordCost]

What the fuck?

Whispers.

[MirrorMask]

What makes it even weirder, in a prog forum where in all the survivors I've done being a long track half guarantees you to go to the end, is that Whispers was the one risking to be voted out instead of TEOF, rather than the very standard Dressed to Kill.

It's like Learning to Live losing narrowly to Metropolis while Wait for Sleep gets a single vote.

[Scorpion]

Geez, good job at eliminating the best thing that SX have ever done!

Whispers, I guess. Though I don't particularly care.

[jjrock88]

This is the reason that I would prefer the rules of Survivors be that you have to actually post your vote in the thread as well.  I really think thats the only way to keep these things legit.

No way Edge of Forever should be out of this survivor.

[ToT-147]

This is the reason that I would prefer the rules of Survivors be that you have to actually post your vote in the thread as well.  I really think thats the only way to keep these things legit.

No way Edge of Forever should be out of this survivor.

I can't see the reason why we should be doing that... I mean, apart from the fact that it would be impossible, since not everyone likes posting after they vote, and even less ppl would do that every single time..

The song should be out, because it was voted out, end of story..

[IDontNotDoThings]

Even as someone who voted for TEOF, I couldn't tell you what happened there? I'm as surprised as you are.

[wolfking]

This is the reason that I would prefer the rules of Survivors be that you have to actually post your vote in the thread as well.  I really think thats the only way to keep these things legit.

No way Edge of Forever should be out of this survivor.

I can't see the reason why we should be doing that... I mean, apart from the fact that it would be impossible, since not everyone likes posting after they vote, and even less ppl would do that every single time..

The song should be out, because it was voted out, end of story..

Jason does have a point to a degree.  I just feel that people that are voting for something that is pretty controversial, should at least post that they voted and maybe why.  I don't always write the song when it's a no brainer, but I always like to when it's a split decision or something not many others would vote for.

Yeah, the song was voted out, but I for one would like to know reasons it was voted before say Whispers or DTK.  And only 1 person out of 5 posted that they voted for it.  At least if the posters posted that they voted for it, it may not leave such a bitter taste.