Anyone else receive a box set even after being refunded? I know a few people here were in that boat, but there wasn't much discussion as to what the protocol would be in such a situation.
The protocol is to do the honest thing and return it or ask to be charged for it if you want to keep it.
Wow... some people's morals are incredibly strong. I'd consider myself a really good human being but there's no way I'd send it back... funny where peope draw their lines... in the sand.
I would keep it. After all they put you through and how inconvenient it would be to return it, just hold on to it. That $125 is a drop in the bucket and lets face it, this didn't happen to too many people so its not hurting them much.
Before anybody judges, I'm the type of guy that accidentally stiffed a waitress on a tip and then mailed her an additional 30% (too embarrassed to go back into the restaurant). My dad one time got water to drink at a restaurant and filled his glass with soda. On the way out, he informed the people, they told him not to worry about it and he insisted on paying the extra buck.
So there is a time and a place for doing the right thing but after waiting 6 months for something, doing your part and canceling, and them STILL screwing up and sending it to you, I think you aren't doing anything skeezy but just keeping it.