So Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5 is shockingly bad, even in the context of lowered expectations.
As one outlet put it, it's "Heartbreakingly Bad".
It's just such a bummer. My friends and I are huge fans of the THPS series, and were really hoping this would be at least decent, even if it wasn't a complete return to form. I have so many fond memories of the first four games, with 3 and 4 being among my favorite games of all time. Having played them pretty frequently throughout the years, including a lot in the past month or so, they both still hold up really well.
5 isn't just "not as good" or "different". It's really bad.
The worst thing is that, aside from a big mis-step with the 'slam' mechanic (which wouldn't even really be an issue if they hadn't mapped it to a single press of the grind button), they actually got the feel down pretty well. At least, when the game actually decides to work properly.
The inclusion of online lobbies between missions is baffling in its current form. You have no real interaction with the other players. If you choose to do online multiplayer, it takes you out of that lobby, and connects you with different players. You have to interact with this lobby, because it's where you start goals from (which don't activate half the time). When you start a goal, it takes you out of that map, loads the same map without other skaters, and then loads back to the lobby afterward (also, most of the goals are really dull). Even if you specifically tell it to go offline, it automatically puts you into an online lobby after one session.
The levels themselves are just... not interesting. They just feel very sparse and lifeless.
There are a lot of other small nitpicks and issues all over the place as well. Giantbomb.com has a good in depth look at it (If you're not familiar with Jeff Gerstmann, one of the guys in that video, if anyone was going to find the silver lining in this game, it would be him).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3IZzXOdVkFUMaybe most inexcusably, there's no 'Horse' multiplayer game type.
It's not the absolute worst game I've ever played, but it may well be the most disappointing.
It's a shame too, because it seems like the developers really wanted to make a good Tony Hawk game, but were given a shoestring budget and an impossibly rushed schedule.
I guess we at least still have 3 and 4, but this is a sad note for the series to go out on, which it probably will.