Just completed the first listen. Some thoughts:
- Condemned to the Gallows is the most consistent song of the bunch, but this could also be because I have heard it so many times and had so much time already to get to love it so much.
- The similarities to Tommy's solo albums brought both the good and bad along with it. There's some solid simpler songwriting on this, but it also has some of the most awkward melodies I've heard from the band in Millions and House Organ and, oh my god, yelloooow, yelloooow, yelloooooooooooow
- Yellow Eyes, beside that one moment, is amazing! Doesn't work as well as one cohesive piece like Condemned to the Gallows does, but there's tons of amazing ideas in that song, including sounds I've never heard from the band.
- Heavy dirty keyboard riff in House Organ is very tasty.
- Blot is not up there with songs lke White Walls and Silent Flight like some have claimed, that whole "computer, simulate" section is waaay overrated, seriously don't get what's so special about that?? The song is really good nonetheless, especially the ending which is kind of like a weaker version of the Silent Flight finale.
- Millions is definitely the worst song on the album for me right now, not sure if that just means I prefer their heavier sound, but probably just because it's the least interesting song.
I'm pretty neutral about this. Based on the single I expected this to blow all other 2018 releases out of the water, but Automata II is of the same quality I'm not even sure if it would be my AOTY right now (meaning it'd have to beat Orphaned Land).