Um. Third option, I guess? I certainly don't try everything, but I can't exactly relate to the 'try nothing' mentality, either.
For instance, I've tried alcohol, I just don't seem to like it very much. I've yet to find an alcoholic beverage I actually enjoy the taste of. I mean, I've had some fruity drinks that tasted pretty good, but they would have tasted just as good, if not better, without the alcohol. It was the fruity I enjoyed, not the booze. Same think with whiskey and coke - it tasted alright to me, but a plain old coke tasted miles better. Meanwhile, I've tried straight whiskey, and thought it tasted like shit. I've tried wines, champagnes, vodka, rum, gin, and a few different beers, and none of it has appealed to me.
Plus, while I've never gotten drunk, I've gotten tipsy, and quite frankly I hated it. I don't like the feeling of losing control of myself or my senses, and that was exactly how being tipsy felt to me: like I was just slightly out of control.
So, I've certainly tried alcohol, but I don't drink it very often. It's not because I'm afraid of liver disease or blackouts or anything like that, it's just that I don't like the taste and I don't like feeling tipsy, so I've got no reason to drink alcohol.
Cigarettes? Never tried em, never will. Everyone in my family smokes, so all my life I've had front row seats to all the damage it can do.
Tattoos? Sure! I don't have any yet, but I'm pretty confident that I'll get one in the next couple years. In fact, I'm thinking about getting that symbol in my avatar. Sitting on the idea for a while before I make a decision, but I might end up doing it.
So, yeah, third option. I don't really worry about how many times I'm going to live, I just sort of take life on a case-by-case basis.