Alright, something that Dillster suggested: as a normal tiebreaker would (or should) offer the same results, I'll be doing two songs against each other, with both the losers being eliminated. The match-ups were determined by having Excel give me two random numbers between one and four. My vote goes to Wollt ihr das Bett in Flammen sehen? on this one.
Once again, 48 hours. Go!