Awake. It's at my #5 spot, inbetween 8V at #4 and I&W at #6. FII is my #9, above BCSL and WDADU. It has great moments, but the stress from the record company and Desmond Child's contributions brought it down a LOT.
Favourite songs on Awake are easily The Mirror, Voices, Scarred, and Space-Dye Vest, but every song is great. Least favourite is Innocence Faded, but still a great rocker.
FII, on the other hand, has Trial of Tears, which is my #2 DT song of all time, which is surprising considering the album's low rank, but it's their least consistent album by far. NM is decent, followed by the cheesy YNM, followed by the great PS, followed by an okay HY, and then BMS, which is a cool song in its own right. And then comes HK which is epic from beginning to end, leading into LITS, a great song, the only spot on the album where two great songs are next to eachother. Afterwards it's a similar pattern until the end.