I voted "Average"
I like the songs, but for DT it's just an average album.
In the Presence of Enemies 8.5/10 - If the second part was much better than the first I'd definitley have to rate it higher, but this is a pretty good song (even though most of the time I just listen to pt.1)
Forsaken 5/10 - Decent radio friendly song that I don't really listen to much, they have better slower ballads that I'd rather listen to. This is one of the first songs that comes up when you search "Dream Theater" in youtube, and strangely some people know them for it.I'll always remember someone saying "Oh yeah, Dream Theater... don't they write about Vampires and stuff?"
Damn you, Forsaken video. It's a good thing Dream Theater isn't Muse, or this song would have been in Twilight.
Constant Motion 6.5/10 - Pretty cool metal song that you can't listen to too much but I enjoy it from time to time. The drumming is completely awesome, especially during the solo. When I first got into DT I listened to this song a lot
The Dark Eternal Night 6/10 - I feel pretty much the same about this song as I do about Constant Motion, except it's longer and just not as strong (chorus wise, verses...)
Repentance 6/10 - This is a song I rarely listen to (Actually I've honestly only listened to it in its entirety maybe 2-3 times) but It's a great part of the 12 Step Suite, and very different for DT, I like it much more now than I did 2 years ago.
Prophets of War 7/10 -Yes. I enjoy PoW, and I've seen live versions, it's better live. A great Labrie vocal performance (And portnoys awesome backing vocals), and shows what I love about Dream Theater, even though everything doesn't work (At least for me, portnoys speaking section) it still shows them trying something eccentric and different than their other stuff.
Ministry of Lost Souls 7.5/10 - Not as good as ITPoE, but still good. The instrumental section (at least I think) is pretty cool, done much better than Endless Sacrifice for example. It's a pretty standard DT song for the most part, and I don't listen to it much.
Anyways, I decided to do a little review, just my opinions on the songs