I really love Anathema as well, they're in my top5 bands at least.
I'd say all their albums after Eternity are flawless, with my favorite being Judgement.
The Silent Enigma is a masterpiece as well, and the only 2 albums i'm not really hooked on is Eternity and their first album, which i just forgot the name of.
I guess Eternity will get me hooked, but their first albums feels really "meh", seeing as Vinny doesn't sing on it.
Overall my favorite tracks would be something like:
2. Emotional Winter
3. Forgotten Hopes
5. Temporary Peace
But then again, i haven't heard the new tracks...