I feel like SC is starting to age postively for the community, but BCSL is not. Where are we at now? How do they compare?
To me, they both have some really solid parts. I think that BCSL definitely has better individual moments than SC (end of TCOT, intro to ANTR, Beautiful Agony, JP solo in TSF) but all of BCSL's songs have some issues, such as being too long or including pointless instrumental duels. SC, on the other hand, has some solid, solid songs that I can't find issues with (ITPOE, CM, Forsaken).
Right now, I'm voting "tied" because I really can't decide.