Love the thread, great idea OP!
For me on I&W it's definitely Glass Moon... I mean that song is in a tough spot... But it is awesome, I think after I went to see them at Radio City and kept listening to the track when they released Score made me appreciate it more... That bass is awesome.
On Awake it's definitely Lifting Shadows for me... Love Lie, and always waiting for Scarred... Poor songs right in between em...
FII is much harder... Really not a fan of "You Not Me" forget Desmond Child... I actually kind of like Burning My Soul, it's catchy... And Lines is one of my favorites... So I'd say Hells Kitchen gets kind of lost... Take Away My Pain maybe too actually, though I think Just Let Me Breathe is kind of a weak track... Still following up Lines? Hard task to beat Take Away my Pain!
Scenes, I have to agree with you all on "One Last Time" Also Through Her Eyes, I mean it's a soft song, but it's not Spirit Carries On, and it's in between Beyond This Life and Home
Definitely not a huge Six Degrees and Train of Thought fan...
Definitely has to be Answer and I Walk Beside You but, I don't know if that's because I'm not the biggest fan of those two songs... Sacrificed Sons definitely gets lost in between Never Enough and 8VM... Though aside from the awesome instrumental passages dunno how big a fan I am of the rest of SS...
Can't really comment on SC and BC since I haven't gotten into them as much...
Definitely don't forget Perfect Strangers on ACoS "EP"