After reading this thread I have realised that I appear to be one of the Trivium fans in the minority who prefer The Crusade over In Waves (so shoot me). My story is probably similar to most, I became aware of Trivium in 2005 when there was lots of hype surrounding them. I got Ascendancy and fell in love with it, still love it. 2005 was really an incredible year for music and especially metal (seriously, wiki the albums released that year, the class of 2005 were strong) so after loving their second album I eagerly awaited their third.
The Crusade was a shift in style, they were never shy about admitting their love for Metallica and being a huge Metallica fan myself I wasn't complaining. I still preferred Ascendancy but loved some of the songs on The Crusade (Entrance of the Conflagration and And Sadness will Sear especially). When Shogun came out I was still hyped on them and although I didn't love it at first it has grown to be my #2 album.
However when In Waves came out I was REALLY underwhelmed. Even now I struggle to name one song other than the title track. I don't know what it was, I knew it sounded good and thought it would grow but it never did. Nothing really grabs me in any of the songs. I just thought it was very bland. I kind of lost interest in Trivium after this but always kept my eye on them. When they released the first single off their last album (Vengance Falls?) I thought I would give it a listen on Spotify. It immediately struck me how much Matt sounded like he was trying to sing like the guy from Disturbed. I did some research and realised the David Draiman was producing the album and that his influence was going to be all over it. This turned me off big style as I think Disturbed are well overrated and I am not a fan at all. I never even gave the album a chance.
Jump forward to this year and one of Trivium's singles pops up on my FB news feed. I thought "I'll give it a go, what have I got to lose." I was pleasantly surprised and really liked it, I have since checked out the other videos they have released and am actually really looking forward to the new album (Anyone else?). Something about it just feels right, sometimes for me the imagery that goes with an album (Album art, band image etc) can really help sell it to me and there is something about the new release that intrigues me.
Anyway, what I am trying to say I guess is that after losing faith in Trivium over two albums (one of which appears to be somewhat of a favourite with a lot of people on here judging by this thread??) I am feeling that I am really getting the urge to get back into them. I have been spinning In Waves over the last few days and I am starting to warm to it a bit. I am looking forward to the new album and will probably buy it on release day. I am also proud to say that I prefer The Crusade over In Waves (I can't be the only one). My album ranking is as follows:
1. Ascendancy
2. Shogun
3. The Crusade
4. Ember to Inferno
5. In Waves
6. Vengance Falls? (Baring in mind I haven't even listened to it but judging from the comments on here I've probably made the right call)