DreamTheaterForums.org Dream Theater Fan Site
Dream Theater => Dream Theater => Topic started by: ? on July 12, 2013, 02:06:20 AM
-
I'm surprised I couldn't find a thread for this brilliant song. Appreciate DT's first epic here! :) It's one of my top 3 songs on WDADU and I hope DT will bring it back on the new tour, no matter if it's preceded by Another Hand or not.
(I'll let someone else comment on the LATM version first :P)
-
If we forget about JP's toooone, an amazing version, much better than the original recording. My favorite song on WDADU. James performance makes the song shine even brighter. Time to hear it live again, last tour AFIL was great but i hope they play TKH this time. EDIT: in case they play anything from WDADU.
-
I love the Christmas 1996 version! (here's the first video of it)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1-Dk95Iy4QU
-
Well... my nickname talks by itself. Amazing song, simply amazing.
-
I love the Christmas 1996 version! (here's the first video of it)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1-Dk95Iy4QU
Nice version! The end of the video is funny :lol
-
One song I'd love to hear them play live, especially seeing how they nailed AFIL on the last tour.
-
Epic song, great riffing.
-
I love the Christmas 1996 version! (here's the first video of it)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1-Dk95Iy4QU
Nice version! The end of the video is funny :lol
. . . and the description. Watch out Rich Wilson :lol
Did you upload the video, Wasteland?
-
LATM version is one of my favorite DT songs ;)
-
My favorite from wdadu!
*appreciates* :hefdaddy
-
I can't believe no has said "I am the killing haaaaaaaaaaaaaaand yet.
Great song.
-
Appreciate DT's first epic here! :)
I love A Change of Seasons. :metal
-
I really like the LatM version...but finding out (a long time ago) that most of the vox were re-recorded soiled it a bit for me. Now I pretty much consider the WDADR version to be definitive.
I've got a "lazy day" today (first one in a very long time)...I think I'll watch that today.
-
The only song from WDADU suffers from absence of James. But none the less, it's in my top 10, live or recording.
-
The only song from WDADU suffers from existence of James. But none the less, it's in my top 10, live or recording.
hmm.... I've always though James did a great job with it :-\
-
The only song from WDADU suffers from existence of James. But none the less, it's in my top 10, live or recording.
hmm.... I've always though James did a great job with it :-\
:rollin :rollin fool me.
I mean absence. :facepalm:
-
I really like the LatM version...but finding out (a long time ago) that most of the vox were re-recorded soiled it a bit for me. Now I pretty much consider the WDADR version to be definitive.
I've got a "lazy day" today (first one in a very long time)...I think I'll watch that today.
That notion should not soil it for you. The original performance was almost equal, and many a time during that tour it happened that James delivered an even better one.
-
The only song from WDADU suffers from existence of James. But none the less, it's in my top 10, live or recording.
hmm.... I've always though James did a great job with it :-\
:rollin :rollin fool me.
I mean absence. :facepalm:
That's a relief ;D The song never did much for me within the context of WDADU either.
-
Yes, I don't like this "LATM is not James' real performance" debate cos of re-recording vox. There are many performance on youtube equal to them or even better.
-
I really like the LatM version...but finding out (a long time ago) that most of the vox were re-recorded soiled it a bit for me.
That notion should not soil it for you. The original performance was almost equal, and many a time during that tour it happened that James delivered an even better one.
-
LATM version is my fav Labrie moment. :tup
-
LATM version is one of my favorite DT songs ;)
I heard this version before the original. :tup
-
Awesome song. I love the video from the WDADU era where JP is describing what it's about, which is a bunch of weird stuff. I agree that the LATM version is superior, but I also really love the acoustic guitar opening on the studio version.
-
The live version on the Hollow Years CD single beats all others
-
The live version on the Hollow Years CD single beats all others
No, James isn't at the top of his game there. He was on better shape 5 months later when the new arrangement made its european debut in April 1997. Same arrangement (with slight improvements), great vocal delivery. (for reference there's the video I posted earlier in this thread)
-
Funny thing about this great little early epic, is that nobody ever points out that it practically has the same basic plot as Black Sabbath's Iron Man (and half a billion other dystopian sci-fi stories) :rollin
But it's a damn great song, fucking hell! :metal
-
It needs to return.