DreamTheaterForums.org Dream Theater Fan Site
Dream Theater => Dream Theater => Topic started by: JayOctavarium on November 04, 2010, 07:44:37 PM
-
Appreciate
Discuss.
:corn
-
4:13-11:30 = win
-
Middle instrumental jam.
F#
DAT SOLO
Kevin's keyboard solo
Myung's bass solo
LaBrie's final vocal moment
Epic fade-out
*Appreciates all of these*
-
It's a pretty cool song.
-
0:00-11:30 = win
FTFY :tup
-Marc.
-
0:00-11:30 = win
FTFY :tup
-Marc.
Beat me to it.
-
It's one of my favorite DT songs. Myung tears it the fuck up.
-
Thank you for making this thread. My favorite song of all time, and that probably won't ever change. DAT F# AND DAT SOLO :hefdaddy :hefdaddy :hefdaddy :hefdaddy :hefdaddy
-
Perfect song.
0:00-11:30 = win
FTFY :tup
-Emindead.
Beat me to it.
-
Thank you for making this thread. My favorite song of all time, and that probably won't ever change. DAT F# AND DAT SOLO :hefdaddy :hefdaddy :hefdaddy :hefdaddy :hefdaddy
Perfect song.
These so much.
-
Learning to Live = MUSIC WIN!
-
There was no time for pain
No energy for ange
-
r
Sightlessness of hatred slips away
-
This has been some of DT's songs that has grown slowest on me.
But now, after a loooooot of listens over the years, I'm really starting to like it! :biggrin:
Would've been cool if DT could make something new in that same style in the future, but they seem to be in a completely different musical state at the moment.
*Appreciates*
-
I know most people go straight to the F# part, and so am I. This is one of the most mind-blowing epic things I've ever heard. Ever seen Tenacious D, when he blows that guy's mind? Thats what happens every time I hear it. I usually listen to that part 3 or 4 times before I move on with the rest of the song. Musically, it's my favorite part ever.
-
I think the F# part is overrated and a little naff to be honest. The F# in the live versions of Metropolis (Marquee) and LtL (OIALT) are superior. Short and sweet.
-
sir, gtfo
-
Haha, I don't see what's so great about it eh. Its just ascending whoa's. The other ones I mentioned are integrated into the main melody, which I think makes them a lot more effective.
-
As good as it is, it is kind of pointless to the song. If he hit an F# while singing the chorus, it would be completely different.
-
As good as it is, it is kind of pointless to the song. If he hit an F# while singing the chorus, it would be completely different.
Pretty much what I said. I agree.
-
Still impressive though, but not the highlight of this gem of a song.
-
The F# and the Wait for Sleep reprise make this song awesome.
-
I think the unison is quite awesome as well.
-
My favourite DT song. It's sheer perfection from start to finish. And the ending is so great, though (or even because) it doesn't try too hard to be epic.
-
There was no time for pain
No energy for ange
:lol Ange hates it when I have no energy for her.
-
LTL is a top 3 DT song for me! Everything about it is great! It features some of the best performances by each member.
-
Top 3 DT song for me. On a good day it's #1.
-
What an uncontroversial thread :lol
It's a good song, originally I didn't think it was one of the greats of Images and Words but now I definitely do. Still only 3rd best from the album for me though. But a top 20 song.
I really like the ending of it for some reason.
-
It took a while for this to grow on me, but now I consider it one of their best songs. Definitely John Myung's greatest lyrical contribution to DT. And an appropriate album closer too, despite the fade-out.
All together now:
Whaa-HAAA-HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!!!!
-
the best DT song... period. any other opinion is objectively incorrect. For me though, I'd say Octavarium (song) would probably come second.
-
I would love to have professional video footage of the KM-era DT doing this song. I was disappoint when they said on the Tokyo DVD commentaries that the encore from that show was LtL but it didn't get included. But the LSFNY version is great too.
-
Appreciates.
-
F#
-
This song is among the most universally loved in the DT catalogue (with good reason), so I'm not really sure why it needed an appreciation thread. But whatever.
*appreciates*
-
^
So that we can declare our appreciation to each other and the world.
*appreciates s'more*
-
Yes, but LTL already gets plenty of that. Most appreciation threads are for songs that people feel may not be getting enough appreciation already.
But again, hey, whatever.
-
Makes all the difference... in LEARNING TO LIVE!!
#1 DT song.
-
Yes, but LTL already gets plenty of that. Most appreciation threads are for songs that people feel may not be getting enough appreciation already.
But again, hey, whatever.
Well we were all nerd raging over LTL not making moffatt's top 50 and the thread devolved after that, so a topic needed to be made :P
-
One of DT's best. All time. Appreciation well deserved. Thank you. That's all.
-
Definitey one of the band's best two or three songs; it is awesome in every way.
Also, I think the F# gets overstated. This song is awesome from start to finish, yet it seems like that is the first thing people think of when this song is mentioned. Honestly, I had been listening to this song for over 10 years before I even heard about this F#, and then I didn't even know where it was for a while after that. When I figured it out, I was like, "Oh yeah, that part is cool," but I don't touch myself at night thinking about it like others seem to. Just saying, is all...;) :p
-
*Appriciates*
Woah woah waahh.
I would kill to see an inform James hit that note live.
Evident that DT needs more JMX lyrics.
-
I would love to have professional video footage of the KM-era DT doing this song. I was disappoint when they said on the Tokyo DVD commentaries that the encore from that show was LtL but it didn't get included. But the LSFNY version is great too.
This will be some of the unfortunate fall-out from the MP departure; probably little chance of getting updated/improved versions of prior releases.
Oh, and can someone tell me again why the F# has yet to be featured on a DVD? Every live version we have of that song, James opts out and tries something different in that spot. OK, well, technically only 2 full versions: Live Scenes from New York and Bucharest. Still . . .
-
Third favorite song, behind Octavarium and Trial of Tears. SOOOOOOO GOOOOOOOOD
-
Didn't realize it wasn't appreciated. The intro kinda irks me, but other then that, it's awesome.
-
One of my favorites parts is:
I hear kindness, beauty, and TRUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUTH!!!
-
The intro kinda irks me, but other then that, it's awesome.
???
-
Definitey one of the band's best two or three songs; it is awesome in every way.
Also, I think the F# gets overstated. This song is awesome from start to finish, yet it seems like that is the first thing people think of when this song is mentioned. Honestly, I had been listening to this song for over 10 years before I even heard about this F#, and then I didn't even know where it was for a while after that. When I figured it out, I was like, "Oh yeah, that part is cool," but I don't touch myself at night thinking about it like others seem to. Just saying, is all...;) :p
This entire post.
-J
-
i think learning to live is a pretty cool guy. eh hits f#5 and doesnt afraid of anything.
-
Definitey one of the band's best two or three songs; it is awesome in every way.
Also, I think the F# gets overstated. This song is awesome from start to finish, yet it seems like that is the first thing people think of when this song is mentioned. Honestly, I had been listening to this song for over 10 years before I even heard about this F#, and then I didn't even know where it was for a while after that. When I figured it out, I was like, "Oh yeah, that part is cool," but I don't touch myself at night thinking about it like others seem to. Just saying, is all...;) :p
This entire post.
-J
:tup
-
It's really hard for me to rank DT songs but I think Learning To Live would probably come in number 1.
-
But in all seriousness, this is an absolute favorite of mine. Top 5, for sure. I'll find myself singing the ending for entire days.
-
I can't separate LTL from Wait For Sleep, so I'll appreciate both.
*appreciates*
-
I can't separate LTL from Wait For Sleep
This. I always try to listen to them together.
-
I've never had a problem listening both independently. WFS and LTL are fantastic songs, but not indispensable to each other.
-
I've never had a problem listening both independently. WFS and LTL are fantastic songs, but not indispensable to each other.
This.
-
I only ever listen to WFS when I'm listening to the album as a whole.
-
LTL works perfectly on its own; the WFS part is a nice addition but it doesn't make it necessary to listen to WFS beforehand every time I want to hear LTL imo.
-
WFS just leads into LTL so perfectly. If I listen to LTL on it's own, I feel like I'm starting the song in the middls.
-
OH MY GOD
If you haven't listened to the YtseJamRecords Bootleg for New York 1993, it will BLOW YOUR MIND. Learning to Live is now officially my favorite DT song! :metal :2metal: :metal :2metal: :metal :2metal: :metal :2metal: \m/
-
I've never had a problem listening both independently. WFS and LTL are fantastic songs, but not indispensable to each other.
Yeah they both stand alone well, but I prefer listening to them both :)
-
The intro kinda irks me, but other then that, it's awesome.
???
I'm not saying it's bad. I've grown used to it. But initially I felt that getting the song off to it's dramatic interlude faster would've helped, especially coming right off of WFS. But that portion is by no means bad. I've grown quite a custom to it.
-
EDIT: double post
-
OH MY GOD
If you haven't listened to the YtseJamRecords Bootleg for New York 1993, it will BLOW YOUR MIND. Learning to Live is now officially my favorite DT song! :metal :2metal: :metal :2metal: :metal :2metal: :metal :2metal: \m/
THIS!!!!
Holy crap, this is the best version of LtL I've ever heard. I can't get over how just... absoultely stunning it is. I just wish the bass was higher in the mix, because this is honestly one of my favorite basslines.
-
As good as it is, it is kind of pointless to the song. If he hit an F# while singing the chorus, it would be completely different.
Pretty much what I said. I agree.
I sooo disagree. In my mind, you have quite a big, instrumental build-up, with the vocals adding the final, epic touch before one of the most moving solo's Petrucci has ever done. Without the WOAH's, the solo wouldn't have felt so epic.
Amazing song!
-
Didn't understand the beauty for it until just recently.
This song is really beautiful. Everything about this song, I should say, is really beautiful. The chorus gets me every time and the instrumental sections is amazing.
Also, one of the greatest Labrie notes ever to be hit. And the guitar solo, WFS reprise, and the ending is super glorious. Definitely one of the songs I'd enjoy listening to over and over again.
-
It is truly an epic lots of instrumental passages and the breakdown is awesome plus that Waiting for sleep theme made it more epic.
-
Mega bump is mega
-
Missed this originally.
If I was forced to say what my favorite DT song is, I'd probably say this. The "outro" feels like it keeps going after the "chorus," even though JLB has some incredible vocals. Only thing that holds it back is production IMO.
-
Herrick's second favorite song from Images and Words. It's kind of a weird song with that one heavy section with the cool rhythm. Or maybe the song isn't weird but that heavy section is? Great song!
Also, I don't mind when an old thread is bumped.
-
My post near the top of this page is nearly 7 years old. :lol
-
I remember being no more than 12 years old and wondering how they could have ever come up with such a masterpiece.
-
Obligatory. Never gets old.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A5g8tzwi_Rk
-
Obligatory. Never gets old.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A5g8tzwi_Rk
Sexcellent!
-
Obligatory. Never gets old.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A5g8tzwi_Rk
Holy shit I've just had a boner.